Where’s the Diversity? The NY Times Top 10 Bestsellers List

As we near the end of the 2013, we enter the season when major newspapers and magazines release their “Best of [enter year] lists”. So naturally we were curious about the level of representation of authors of color in last year’s New York Times Top 10 Bestsellers list. We chose to look at their most general bestsellers list, Combined Print & E-Book Fiction (adult), and looked at the top ten books for all 52 weeks of 2012. The results were staggering, if not surprising in light of our past Diversity Gap studies of the Academy AwardsThe Tony Awards, The Emmy Awards, the children’s book industry, and US politics, where we analyzed multi-year samplings and found a disturbingly consistent lack of diversity.

NY Times Bestseller List infographic

NY Times Bestseller List infographic (click for larger image)

A few noteworthy facts we discovered while conducting the study:

  • Only three out of the 124 authors who appeared on the list during 2012 are people of color
  • No African American authors made the Top 10 Bestsellers list that we looked at in 2012
  • Of the three books/book series by authors of color that made the list, only one contains a main character of color (Eva Tramell of the Crossfire series is part Latina)

An interview with author Charles Yu (below) helps give a glimpse of life as a living and working author of color in today’s marketplace.

Charles Yu

Charles Yu is the author of three books, including How to Live Safely in a guest blog iconScience Fictional Universe, which was a New York Times Notable Book and named one of the best books of the year by Time magazine. His latest is Sorry Please Thank You, which was named one of the best books of the year by the San Francisco Chronicle. Charles can find him on Twitter @charles_yu

Do the statistics for The New York Times Top 10 Bestsellers list surprise you? 

Charles Yu: A little bit—maybe because in the spheres of my interest, there’s a fair amount of diversity of authors’ backgrounds. The NYT list, especially the top 10 or top 15, is really rarefied territory, though. Even books that are quite “big” can be far off from even being in the vicinity of the bottom of that list. It just takes an immense amount of distribution and exposure to get on the list.

Did your parents encourage you to pursue a career in the arts?

CY: They encourage my writing, but not necessarily as a career, and I think in some ways that is just realistic of them. They overcame a lot, sacrificed a lot, to give me opportunities here, and the odds are just so heavily against having enough success in the arts to make it viable as a livelihood, that I really understand. I would imagine I was not the only one.

Do you think part of the problem of why there is a lack of diversity among authors of adult fiction is because immigrant families tend to steer their children away from jobs in entertainment and toward stable jobs such as doctors and lawyers?

CY: I have Asian American friends and acquaintances in a wide range of fields who have or have not made certain kinds of choices, have or have not pursued careers in arts, entertainment, or other creative fields, who are currently in all different kinds of situations professionally, and their parents and circumstances and decisions have varied all over the map. But one common theme (at least for those roughly my age) is that they felt a gravitational effect, or funneling or some pressure, to go to grad school or professional school, to choose certain kinds of safe/lucrative/stable professions. Some of that’s part of the immigrant generational curve. The first wave comes (in my parents’ case, as part of a big influx of engineering/medical/science students from Taiwan starting in 1965), and they plant a foothold, socio-economically and culturally. They find good neighborhoods, companies, and school districts. And they want their kids to consolidate that socio-economic progress. But the success they have had, my parents and their cohort, that is the stability and the opportunity that allows someone like me to take more chances and to feel comfortable enough, in a lot of ways, including in a sense of being part of the culture, of the mainstream, to think I might be able to write a novel. So I would say that things are a lot different now, even just a generation later. For my kids and their kids, the amount of opportunity will just continue to improve.

When I read your book How to Live Safely in a Science Fictional Universe I was struck by the complexity and familiarity that the main character had with his father. It was refreshing to see an Asian family in a How to Live Safely in a Science Fictional Universesetting that was not stereotypical. Family depictions like yours are extremely rare in science fiction. How important was it to you to depict an Asian family in your book? Do you feel the inclusion of an Asian family hindered or helped the marketability of your novel?

CY: It was critical to me to have an Asian family. That was a necessary ingredient of the particular story I was telling about those particular characters. I don’t know if it helped or hindered marketability. If I had to guess, I’d say the title itself probably already (whether justifiably or not) creates an impression that it is going to be a certain kind of book, or in a certain genre or subgenre. I have received some personal feedback from readers who identified with the father-son relationship, or the family, including Asians, Asian Americans, Taiwanese Americans in particular. And I haven’t gotten any negative feedback that people felt that the ethnicity of the characters made it hard to relate to them.

As a reader, do you support other authors of color by seeking out and reading their books?

CY: I do—maybe not in any explicit program of seeking out, but in terms of the kinds of stories I am drawn to, in terms of me naturally seeking out a diversity of voices, yes. I am always looking for books outside my natural circle of curiosity. I have my own obsessions, things I can’t get away from, a region of natural interest, and I am continually circumnavigating that territory, keeping up on what’s new in there, deepening my knowledge of the area. I’m always trying to widen that circle, and it’s easy to see the stuff that’s adjacent, that’s close by, and include that. What I really need is to find books that are far from that circle, and for that, I rely on recommendations, happenstance, intentionally mixing it up—trying things that I think I might really not like—and, above all, staying as open as I can to things that don’t fit in with my normal patterns of reading and thinking.

Do you picture yourself writing a book one day that will be on The New York Times Top 10 Bestsellers list?

CY: Not really, and I think that could be a part of the problem in and of itself, that it’s not something I can conceive of as being reasonably realistic. I don’t know if it is expressly the lack of diversity that makes it seem so out of reach, but on some level, perhaps I’ve got this sort of tacit assumption that because of my particular background and areas of interest, it seems implausible for someone like me. I’m not sure I’m specifically striving to make the bestseller list, but just thinking about it (as a result of your question) is an interesting and I think ultimately fruitful conversation to have. 

***

While The New York Times Top 10 Bestsellers list Diversity Gap study covered the state of adult fiction bestsellers, these two articles below turn the focus back on children’s and YA  booksellers:

“The New York Times released their list of Notable Children’s Books of 2013. And once again, they failed to include a single title written by or about Latinos. In fact, in the last 10 years only one book featuring a Latino protagonist and written by a Latino author – Marcelo in the Real World written by Francisco X. Stork in 2009 – has been included in the annual list.” —Monica Olivera, NBC Latino contributor

Read the full article

The librarian blog Stacked did a two part gender disparity study of YA New York Times bestsellers that is a must read. Part I | Part II

***

This is not an isolated incident, but a wide reaching societal problem.
Read more Diversity Gap studies on:

The Tony Awards
The Emmy Awards
The children’s book industry
The Academy Awards
US politics

Further resources on how to teach content and visual literacy using Lee & Low Books’ infographics series on the Diversity Gap:

Using Infographics In The Classroom To Teach Visual Literacy

8 Comments

  1. Betty yu
    Posted December 10, 2013 at 1:59 pm | Permalink

    Thanks NY times

  2. Betty yu
    Posted December 10, 2013 at 2:20 pm | Permalink

    Great interview thanks

  3. Betty yu
    Posted December 11, 2013 at 8:24 am | Permalink

    May be soon enough, he will be on NY times top 10 list.

  4. Posted December 11, 2013 at 6:21 pm | Permalink

    We found this interesting blog post by Tess Gerritsen, one of the three authors of color who did make the top 10 in 2012. The post is candidly honest on why she does NOT make POC as main characters in her books. Personally, I disagree with her publisher’s advice to her and also strongly feel she should use her power as a bestselling author to take some risks and further the cause. Here’s the link: http://www.tessgerritsen.com/blog/your-english-is-so-good/

  5. Ming L
    Posted December 12, 2013 at 11:08 pm | Permalink

    will you do a similar study of 2013 NYT lists? only a few more weeks to go. it would be easy to add those to the cumulative 2013 weeks

  6. Posted January 10, 2014 at 11:30 am | Permalink

    Exactly the kind of response that we wanted to see from doing this study! Big Kudos to Book Riot for simply getting it: http://bookriot.com/2014/01/07/favorite-writers-color/#disqus_thread

  7. Posted January 10, 2014 at 11:31 am | Permalink

    Ming, We have a lot of new Diversity Gap studies coming up for 2014 so stay tuned. We’ll definitely try our best to add 2013 numbers to this existing study.

  8. Jen @ Book Scribbles
    Posted May 3, 2014 at 12:37 pm | Permalink

    Thanks for sharing this infographic! I did a similar project in high school following up on diversity in children’s TV shows and the lack of representation was appalling (though I have to say Disney made some huge gains from what it was creating in the mid-1900s).


27 Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. […] the Top 10 New York Times Bestsellers are just not diverse. Even less than you might […]

  2. […] For more details about their research, check out their post. […]

  3. […] Where’s the Diversity? The NY Times Top 10 Bestsellers List – “Only three out of the 124 authors who appeared on the list during 2012 are people of color” And one of them is E.L. James, who’s apparently half Chilean. They follow up their infographic with an interview with author Charles Yu. […]

  4. […] Diversity Gap in NYT Bestsellers […]

  5. […] It’s embarrassing how easy it is to only read books by white authors. Jason Low looked at the diversity gap in the New York Times Top 10 Bestsellers list, and he found that only three of the 124 authors for appeared on the list were people of color. […]

  6. […] Lee & Low are asking what’s up with the lack of non-white writers on the NY Times top 10 bestseller list (followed by an interview with author Charles Yu). Book Riot is in turn asking who your favorite […]

  7. […] Lee & Low Books did a study about the diversity gap in the New York Times Top 10 Bestsellers List. There were a lot of best-of lists for 2013, and I went through many of them. A commonality with […]

  8. […] by a recent study by Lee & Low Books which revealed that of 124 authors who made the New York Times Top 10 bestseller list in 2012, […]

  9. […] a recent post, the folks at Lee & Low Books called renewed attention to the persistent issue of diversity (or rather, the lack thereof) on the New York Times bestsellers list. Of 124 authors who made the […]

  10. […] by a recent study by Lee & Low Books which revealed that of 124 authors who made the New York Times Top 10 bestseller list in 2012, only […]

  11. […] past Diversity Gap studies of The Tony Awards, The Emmy Awards, the children’s book industry, The New York Times Top 10 Bestseller List, and US politics, where we analyzed multi-year samplings and found a disturbingly consistent lack […]

  12. […] Our other Diversity Gap studies on the Tony Awards, the children’s book industry, US politics, The New York Times Top 10 Bestseller list, and the Academy Awards revealed a disturbing trend in ethnic and gender representation. We […]

  13. […] Academy Awards The Emmy Awards The children’s book industry The New York Times Top 10 Bestseller List US […]

  14. […] previous diversity studies on the Academy Awards, the Emmy Awards, the children’s book field, The New York Times Top 10 Bestseller List, and the Tony Awards, we interviewed people who actively work in television, publishing, and the […]

  15. […] Tony Awards The Emmy Awards The Academy Awards The New York Times Top 10 Bestseller List US […]

  16. […] “only three out of the 124 authors who appeared on the list [were] People of Colour.” (Source) […]

  17. […] of 2013, Lee and Low, an independent children’s book publisher, examined the diversity gap in the New York Times Top 10 Bestsellers of 2012. Only 3 out of the 124 authors who appeared in the Adult Fiction section were people of colour. […]

  18. […] by a by a study by Lee & Low Books that showed the absence of authors of color on the New York Times top 10 bestseller list, Book […]

  19. […] infographics in the series: The Tony Awards,  The Emmy Awards, Children’s Book Publishing, The NY Times Top 10 Bestsellers List, and American Politics. Consider central idea, evidence, format, and […]

  20. […] past Diversity Gap studies of The Tony Awards, The Emmy Awards, the children’s book industry, The New York Times Top 10 Bestseller List, and US politics, where we analyzed multi-year samplings and found a disturbingly consistent lack […]

  21. […] by a by a study by Lee & Low Books that showed the absence of authors of color on the New York Times top 10 bestseller list, Book […]

  22. […] some facts: Last year, only 3 of the 124 bestsellers were written by people of color. That’s 2.5%! Of those three authors, only one wrote a book […]

  23. […] interview with science fiction author Charles Yu has an accompanying graph on how white and male the New York Times bestseller list is, and […]

  24. […] and media? As we researched each study, finding a lack of diversity in television, film, theater, New York Times Bestseller lists, and politics, it became clear that the correlation and consistency of our findings reflect […]

  25. […] our past Diversity Gap studies of the Tony Awards, the Emmy Awards, the children’s book industry, The New York Times Top 10 Bestseller List, US politics, and the Academy Awards, where we analyzed multi-year samplings and found a […]

  26. […] past Diversity Gap studies of the Tony Awards, the Emmy Awards, the children’s book industry, The New York Times Top 10 Bestseller List, US politics, and the Academy Awards, where we analyzed multi-year samplings and found a […]

  27. […] LEE & LOW BOOKS – STATISTICS ON DIVERSITY AND THE NEW YORK TIMES BESTSELLERS LIST […]

Post a Comment

Required fields are marked *
*
*

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 4,575 other followers

%d bloggers like this: